Old-Fashioned Potato Salad Recipes

This is the potato salad my family begs for at every picnic, BBQ, and awkwardly scheduled Sunday dinner — the one with creamy mayo, tangy pickles, and soft-but-not-mushy potatoes. It’s old-fashioned in the best way: simple ingredients, big comfort, and zero pretense. If you want potato salad that tastes like summer and actually holds up on a picnic table without turning into sad mashed potatoes, this is it.

My husband calls this “the good one” and will happily eat it straight from the bowl with a spoon. Our kiddo used to pick out the pickles and leave everything else; now she eats a full scoop and asks for more. It’s become our fallback when guests show up last-minute, because it’s forgiving, feeds a crowd, and somehow feels like a hug. Once I swapped dill for parsley when I was out of the real deal and it was weirdly delicious — lesson learned: don’t fear small swaps.

Kitchen Talk

MORE EASY SIDE DISHES RECIPES...

SIDE DISHES

Bacon Jalapeño Creamed Corn Recipe

SIDE DISHES

Easy English Jacket Potatoes

SIDE DISHES

Easy Corn Casserole Recipe

SIDE DISHES

Easy Cranberry Sauce Recipe

I started making this the way my grandma did, then “improved” it with too much mustard (oops), and finally landed on the version that actually made everyone sit down. The trick I learned the hard way is to let the potatoes cool just enough so the dressing clings but doesn’t melt — there’s a sweet spot between warm and cold where flavors marry and nobody gets soggy salad. Also, I once forgot the salt and it was like chewing cotton; always taste as you go, friends.

Shopping Tips

– Vegetables: Use waxy potatoes (Yukon Gold or red potatoes) so they keep their shape; avoid russets if you want chunkier pieces.
– Eggs: Get fresh eggs for boiling — older eggs peel easier, but very fresh eggs taste better when you’re snacking on yolk.
– Dairy: If you like a silkier dressing, a spoonful of sour cream or yogurt is nice; check the label for full-fat vs low-fat for best texture.
– Spices: Mustard powder or dry mustard can boost depth if your yellow mustard tastes flat; check labels for sodium.
– Fresh Herbs: Dill and parsley are classic; buy bunches with bright stems and no wilting leaves for the best flavor.

Prep Ahead Ideas

– Boil the potatoes a day ahead, cool them, and store in an airtight container; chop up the next day to keep them from going gluey.
– Hard-boil and peel the eggs in advance — store whole in cold water or sliced in a covered container so they don’t dry out.
– Make the dressing a day ahead in a jar and shake it to emulsify; it actually tastes better after a few hours in the fridge.
– Use clear, stackable containers for layers (potatoes on bottom, dressing separate) so you can assemble last-minute without mess.

✔Time-Saving Tricks

– Microwave the potatoes in chunks to cut boiling time — wrap in a damp towel and zap in short intervals until tender.
– Use frozen peas or canned corn straight from the can for color and crunch if you’re in a rush.
– Buy good-quality jarred pickles or relish instead of chopping loose pickles; it’s a tiny cheat that saves time and tastes just fine.
– Make the dressing in a mason jar and shake — less cleanup, faster emulsification.

✔Common Mistakes

– Overcooking potatoes: they turn mushy. If that happens, toss them with a little acid (vinegar or lemon) and a firmer veggie like celery to add texture.
– Not seasoning enough: mayo dulls everything, so season in layers — salt the potatoes when cooking, and taste the dressing.
– Adding dressing while potatoes are piping hot: it’ll absorb too much and get soggy. Let potatoes cool until just warm.
– Using low-quality mustard: flat flavor alert. A tangy, good mustard lifts the whole salad.

What to Serve It With

– Grilled burgers or hot dogs for that classic backyard spread.
– Fried chicken or baked chicken thighs — potato salad is the perfect creamy counterpoint.
– A crisp green salad or coleslaw to add freshness and balance.
– Crusty bread or soft rolls — because carbs are life.

✔Tips & Mistakes

– Salt the cooking water for potatoes like pasta; it seasons from the inside out.
– Chop potatoes to similar sizes so everything cooks evenly.
– If dressing is too thin, whisk in a little more mayo or a sprinkle of dry mustard to thicken.
– I once added too much pickle juice — rescued it with a spoonful of sugar and extra mayo.

✔Storage Tips

Leftovers live happily in an airtight container in the fridge for 3–4 days. Potato salad will firm up as it chills (the mayo tightens), so give it a stir and a little extra mustard or vinegar if it needs brightening before serving again. Don’t freeze potato salad — textures turn sad. Also, yes, I have eaten it cold for breakfast and it is exactly as indulgent/cringe as you’d expect — no judgment here.

✔Variations and Substitutions

– Mayo swaps: half mayo, half Greek yogurt keeps it tangy and cuts fat, but full mayo = classic creaminess.
– Mustard: yellow for nostalgia, Dijon for a sharper edge, or whole-grain for texture.
– Crunch: celery, green onion, or finely chopped bell pepper all work. If you hate celery like I used to, try chopped pickles instead.
– Herbs: dill is classic; parsley or chives are more subtle and won’t fight the other flavors.
– Want bacon? Fry it up and add at the end for smoky crunch — but keep the salt balance in check.

Frequently Asked Questions

Old-Fashioned Potato Salad Recipes

Creamy and tangy, this old-fashioned potato salad pairs tender potatoes with chopped eggs, crunchy veggies, and a classic dressing. Perfect for picnics, potlucks, or make-ahead sides.

Rate This Yum Pin This Recipe For Later! Share The Yum On Facebook Print

Prep Time: 20 minutes minutes

Cook Time: 25 minutes minutes

Total Time: 45 minutes minutes

Servings: 8

Ingredients

 

1x2x3x

Main Ingredients

• ▢ 3 lb Yukon gold potatoes peeled and cubed
• ▢ 1.25 cup mayonnaise
• ▢ 1.5 tbsp yellow mustard
• ▢ 1.5 tbsp apple cider vinegar
• ▢ 2 tsp granulated sugar
• ▢ 1.25 tsp kosher salt plus more to taste
• ▢ 0.5 tsp black pepper freshly ground
• ▢ 0.5 tsp celery seed
• ▢ 1 cup celery small dice
• ▢ 0.5 cup red onion finely chopped
• ▢ 0.33 cup dill pickle relish drained
• ▢ 7 oz hard-boiled eggs about 4 large, chopped
• ▢ 2 tbsp fresh parsley chopped, plus more for garnish
• ▢ 0.5 tsp paprika for garnish

Instructions

Preparation Steps

• Cover potatoes with cold salted water by 1 inch. Boil, then simmer until tender, 10–12 minutes.
• Drain potatoes and spread on a sheet pan to steam-dry until barely warm.
• Hard-boil eggs: cover with water, bring to a boil, cover, rest 10 minutes, then ice-bath, peel, and chop.
• Whisk mayonnaise, mustard, vinegar, sugar, celery seed, salt, and pepper in a large bowl.
• Fold in potatoes, chopped eggs, celery, red onion, and relish until coated. Adjust salt to taste.
• Chill covered at least 30 minutes. Sprinkle with parsley and paprika before serving.

Notes

Stir in chopped dill or sliced scallions for extra freshness, or swap half the mayo for plain Greek yogurt to lighten it up. For picnics, keep the salad chilled on ice and store leftovers in the refrigerator up to 3 days.

This recipe is an original creation inspired by classic Old-Fashioned Potato Salad Recipes flavors. All ingredient ratios and instructions are independently developed.