Amish Macaroni Salad Recipe

This Amish macaroni salad is that slightly sweet, very creamy, crowd-pleasing side that shows up at potlucks, picnics, and the accidental weeknight when you forget what “side dish” even means. Think tender elbow macaroni, crunchy celery and carrot, little pops of pickle/sweet relish, and a tangy mayo-vinegar dressing that mellows in the fridge and somehow gets better the next day. It’s comfort food that doesn’t pretend to be healthy — it’s just reliably delicious.

My husband calls this “the must-eat salad” and will announce it like a holiday whenever I put a bowl out. Our kid requests the crunchy bits like they’re candy. I once made a double batch for a family barbecue and the bowl was empty before the burgers came off the grill — that’s how it became a staple. It’s the kind of thing I throw together when I’m being lazy and everyone thinks I slaved over it. Win-win.

Kitchen Talk

MORE EASY SIDE DISHES RECIPES...

SIDE DISHES

Honey Butter Smashed Potatoes

SIDE DISHES

Easy Parmesan Roasted Potatoes

SIDE DISHES

Herbed Mushroom Spoon Bread Recipe

SIDE DISHES

Easy Sausage Cranberry Stuffing Recipe

I always underestimate how loud this salad is in our fridge — the smell of vinegar and mayo mixing with the sweet relish is oddly comforting. Once I forgot to cool the pasta properly and the dressing soaked in too fast, turning the whole thing into a mushy mess; that taught me to rinse the drained pasta under cold water and let it air-dry a touch. Also, I once swapped sweet pickle relish for chopped dill pickles in a panic — not a disaster, just a tangier, sneakier version that our kid ate faster. The dressing is simple but picky: mix, taste, tweak. Don’t be precious about stirring.

Shopping Tips

– Vegetables: Grab crisp celery and carrots — they’re the salad’s crunch backbone; avoid limp celery stalks that bend like sad noodles.
– Grains/Pasta: Elbow macaroni is classic; choose a good-quality dry pasta and don’t overcook it — al dente holds up better in the fridge.
– Dressing/Oil: You’ll want a neutral mayo and a splash of white vinegar; if you like softer tang, pick apple cider vinegar for a milder note.
– Cheese: If you add a little cheddar, pick a young sharp or mild block and grate it fresh — pre-shredded has weird anti-clump bits that don’t love mayo.
– Fresh Herbs: Parsley or a touch of dill brightens the bowl; buy a small bunch and check for perky stems not floppy ones.

Prep Ahead Ideas

– Cook the pasta, rinse with cold water, and store it in a sealed container in the fridge the day before.
– Chop veggies and hard-boil eggs up to 2 days ahead; keep them in separate airtight containers so they don’t soften the pasta.
– Mix the dressing and refrigerate in a jar; give it a good shake before tossing with the pasta. Assembling the salad the night before lets the flavors marry — chill at least 1 hour, overnight is better.
– Use shallow containers to cool and chill faster; a wide glass bowl or a half-sheet pan lined with parchment works great.

✔Time-Saving Tricks

– Cook pasta while you chop veggies — multitask like you mean it.
– Use pre-shredded carrots or frozen peas (thawed) if you’re short on time; they’re fine in a pinch.
– Swap store-bought sweet pickle relish for chopped pickles if you want texture faster.
– Don’t rush the chilling: even 1 hour improves flavor, but overnight turns it into magic.

✔Common Mistakes

– Overcooking the pasta — I did this once and the salad turned mushy; fix it by tossing the overcooked pasta with ice water and using a little extra dressing.
– Pouring dressing on hot pasta — heat makes mayo break down; always cool the pasta first.
– Too much vinegar right away — add a little, taste, then add more if it needs a kick.
– Letting watery veggies sit in the salad — pat chopped cucumbers or shredded carrots dry if they look juicy to avoid watering down the dressing.

What to Serve It With

– Grilled burgers or hot dogs for a classic picnic combo.
– Pulled pork sandwiches — the salad’s sweetness loves smoky meat.
– A simple green salad to balance the creamy texture.
– Crusty bread or potato chips for extra crunch on the side.

✔Tips & Mistakes

– Stir gently and don’t overmix once the dressing’s in — you don’t want to mash the pasta.
– Salt the pasta water well for flavor; it’s the base of the whole bowl.
– If the salad tastes flat, a small splash more vinegar or a pinch of sugar fixes it fast.
– Leftovers can stiffen; loosen them with a tablespoon or two of mayo or milk when reheating the bowl to serve cold.

✔Storage Tips

Keep leftovers in an airtight container in the fridge for up to 3 days. The salad is totally fine cold — in fact, I’ll eat it straight from the fridge at 7 a.m. with no shame. If it looks dry, stir in a little extra mayo or a splash of milk to revive it. Don’t freeze — the mayo and veg turn sad and watery after thawing.

✔Variations and Substitutions

I’ve swapped sweet relish for chopped dill pickles, added grated cheddar when I wanted more heft, and used Greek yogurt mixed with mayo to cut richness (half-and-half works). If you’re skipping eggs, it’s still great. Avoid swapping mayo entirely for oil — you’ll lose that classic creaminess unless you make a full vinaigrette-style change.

Frequently Asked Questions

Amish Macaroni Salad Recipe

Creamy, sweet-tangy macaroni salad with eggs, crisp veggies, and a classic Amish-style dressing. Perfect for picnics and potlucks.

Rate This Yum Pin This Recipe For Later! Share The Yum On Facebook Print

Prep Time: 20 minutes minutes

Cook Time: 15 minutes minutes

Total Time: 35 minutes minutes

Servings: 8

Ingredients

 

1x2x3x

Main Ingredients

• ▢ 10.5 oz elbow macaroni
• ▢ 1.25 cup mayonnaise
• ▢ 2.5 tbsp yellow mustard
• ▢ 1.5 tbsp apple cider vinegar
• ▢ 2.5 tbsp granulated sugar
• ▢ 2 tbsp milk to loosen the dressing
• ▢ 0.5 tsp celery seed
• ▢ 1.25 tsp fine salt plus more to taste
• ▢ 0.5 tsp black pepper
• ▢ 0.5 cup sweet pickle relish
• ▢ 0.75 cup diced celery
• ▢ 0.5 cup diced red bell pepper
• ▢ 0.5 cup finely chopped sweet onion
• ▢ 4 each hard-boiled eggs, chopped
• ▢ 0.25 tsp paprika for garnish

Instructions

Preparation Steps

• Boil macaroni in well-salted water until tender, 7–9 minutes. Drain and rinse under cold water to cool.
• If needed, cook eggs: simmer in water 10 minutes, then chill, peel, and chop.
• Whisk mayonnaise, mustard, sugar, vinegar, milk, celery seed, salt, and pepper in a bowl until smooth.
• Combine cooled macaroni, celery, onion, bell pepper, relish, and chopped eggs in a large mixing bowl.
• Fold in the dressing until everything is evenly coated. Taste and adjust seasoning.
• Cover and chill at least 1 hour to meld flavors. Dust with paprika before serving.

Notes

Stir in 1/2 cup diced cheddar or a handful of thawed peas for a twist. For make-ahead, keep the dressing separate and toss just before serving. Refrigerate leftovers in an airtight container for up to 3 days.

This recipe is an original creation inspired by classic Amish Macaroni Salad Recipe flavors. All ingredient ratios and instructions are independently developed.