Eggnog Milkshake Recipes

This eggnog milkshake is the holiday chaos you actually want in your life: rich, boozy-if-you-want, spiked with nutmeg and totally unapologetic about being dessert-for-drink. Think thick vanilla ice cream, creamy eggnog, a splash of bourbon or rum (optional), and a crown of whipped cream — all blitzed together until gloriously drinkable. It’s cozy, ridiculous, and exactly what I reach for when I need a seasonal treat that feels special but takes five minutes.

My little family loses their minds over this one. My husband will call from the garage if he hears the blender — true story — and the kids will camp out on the countertop, elbows in, waiting for the whipped cream. It became our unofficial holiday breakfast once when I poured it for them alongside pancakes and then vowed never to apologize for starting the day with frothy goodness. It’s the kind of recipe that shows up at midnight parties, on quiet snowy mornings, and at the end of chaotic dinners when everyone wants to linger. We’ve made it boozy, sober, and once with peppermint extract because I forgot the eggnog—surprisingly great.

Kitchen Talk

MORE EASY DESSERT RECIPES...

DESSERT

No-Bake Peanut Butter Cup Bars

DESSERT

Peaches and Cream Whoopie Pies

DESSERT

Irish Whiskey Brownies

DESSERT

Easy Butterfinger Truffles

Okay, real talk: the first time I made this I tried to be fancy and used homemade eggnog that was still warm. Do not do that. Warm eggnog + blender = sad curdled regrets. I also once toasted the nutmeg and then forgot to put it in — still smelled nice though. Sometimes I swap the bourbon for a coffee liqueur if we’re having dessert for dinner and it somehow makes everything feel sinfully smart. If your blender is a dinosaur, chop the ice cream into chunks so it’ll blend without screaming. Also, crushed gingersnaps rimmed on the glass? Game changer.

Shopping Tips

– Dairy: Pick a rich, full-fat eggnog if you want that creamy, custardy shake; skim versions make it thin and sad.
– Frozen Aisle: Use a good-quality vanilla ice cream — homemade is lovely, but a sturdy commercial pint blends smoother and faster.
– Spices: Freshly grated nutmeg tastes worlds better than pre-ground; cinnamon is a fine backup if you’re in a pinch.
– Eggs: If you buy homemade-style eggnog with raw eggs, make sure it’s pasteurized or intended for drinking; safety first.
– Specialty Item: If you plan to spike it, choose a dark rum or bourbon with a little caramel/vanilla note — it plays nicely with eggnog.

Prep Ahead Ideas

– Freeze eggnog into ice-cube trays to make ultra-thick shakes on demand; pop a few cubes into the blender with ice cream.
– Scoop ice cream into an airtight container so it’s ready for quick blending; leave it slightly softened in the fridge 10–15 minutes before you plan to blend.
– Make a spice mix (nutmeg + cinnamon + a pinch of salt) in a small jar so you can dust glasses fast.
– Store leftover spiked or unspiked milkshake mixture in a sealed bottle in the fridge for up to 12 hours; shake before pouring.

✔Time-Saving Tricks

– Use slightly softened ice cream so the blender doesn’t have to work overtime — 30 seconds at high speed usually does it.
– Pre-measure booze into a small pourer or shot glass if you’re making a bunch of adult shakes.
– Skip fresh grated nutmeg if you’re running late and sprinkle a pinch of ground cinnamon instead; still festive.
– If you’re out of ice cream, frozen banana + extra eggnog and a touch of vanilla can make a decent thick substitute in a pinch.

✔Common Mistakes

– Adding too much liquid: I once emptied a whole carton of eggnog in and ended up with a milkshake the consistency of a milk soup. Fix: add more ice cream or a few frozen eggnog cubes and reblend.
– Warm eggnog: don’t blend it hot — it makes a sad, soupy texture. Chill everything first.
– Over-spiking: a little liquor goes a long way. Taste as you go so it doesn’t hijack the eggnog flavor.
– Forgetting to chill the glass: a cold glass helps keep the shake thick longer; otherwise it melts faster than you can Instagram it.

What to Serve It With

– Gingersnap cookies or biscotti for dunking.
– Warm cinnamon rolls for a ridiculous holiday brunch pairing.
– Salted caramel shortbread or chocolate crinkle cookies to balance the sweetness.
– A tiny cheese plate if you’re serving adults and want to pretend this is sophisticated.

✔Tips & Mistakes

– Use whole-milk eggnog for richness; skim will water things down.
– If the shake is too thick, add milk by the tablespoon, not the cup.
– Nutmeg on top = aroma; grate it last so it doesn’t clump.
– If your blender separates, blitz again at high speed — magic.

✔Storage Tips

Leftovers aren’t glorious, honestly. Store in a sealed jar in the fridge for up to 12 hours and give it a vigorous shake before drinking — it’ll be thinner and a little aerated. If you freeze it, you get ice cream popsicles; great for breakfast if you’re not judging yourself. No shame in warm mornings when cereal isn’t cutting it.

✔Variations and Substitutions

– Booze swaps: bourbon, dark rum, or spiced rum each give distinct personalities — bourbon brings warmth, rum brings molasses vibes.
– Dairy-free: use a thick coconut milk ice cream and canned coconut milk eggnog alternative for a coconut-forward shake.
– Lighter: swap half the ice cream for frozen banana and reduce added sweetener; still creamy but less indulgent.
– Spiced up: add a shot of espresso for a mocha-eggnog mashup, or a splash of peppermint for a candy-cane vibe.
– Kid-friendly: omit liquor, add extra vanilla, and top with crushed candy for the tiny humans.

Frequently Asked Questions

Eggnog Milkshake Recipes

Creamy eggnog blends with vanilla ice cream for a frosty holiday milkshake. Top with whipped cream and a dusting of nutmeg.

Pin This Recipe For Later! Share The Yum On Facebook Print

Prep Time: 10 minutes minutes

Total Time: 10 minutes minutes

Servings: 2

Ingredients

 

1x2x3x

Main Ingredients

• ▢ 2.5 cups vanilla ice cream use full-fat for best texture
• ▢ 1.25 cups chilled eggnog
• ▢ 3 tbsp whole milk add more to thin as needed
• ▢ 1 tsp pure vanilla extract
• ▢ 0.125 tsp ground cinnamon
• ▢ 0.25 tsp ground nutmeg plus a pinch more for garnish
• ▢ 1.5 fl oz dark rum or bourbon optional, for adults
• ▢ 1 cup whipped cream for topping

Instructions

Preparation Steps

• Chill two serving glasses in the freezer while you prep.
• Add ice cream, eggnog, milk, vanilla, cinnamon, and nutmeg to a blender.
• Blend until smooth and thick, about 20–30 seconds. Adjust with a splash of milk if too thick.
• For a spiked shake, pour in rum or bourbon and pulse a few times.
• Pour into chilled glasses. Top with whipped cream and a light sprinkle of nutmeg. Serve right away.

Notes

Variation ideas: Drizzle caramel in the glass, or rim with crushed gingersnaps for crunch. For dairy-free, use plant-based nog and a creamy non-dairy vanilla ice cream. To make ahead, freeze the blended shake in jars with headspace; thaw 10 minutes and re-blend until sippable.

This recipe is an original creation inspired by classic Eggnog Milkshake Recipes flavors. All ingredient ratios and instructions are independently developed.